 |
|
|
Technology
|
|
Traditional
Hardmetals
Hardmetals (cemented carbides)
have been the most widely used super hard tool materials. Hardmetals are a
class of hard, wear-resistant materials in which the hard carbide
particles are bound together, or cemented by a soft and ductile metal
binder.
The first cemented carbide invented in the early 1920s was tungsten carbide (WC) bound by
a cobalt
binder. Cemented carbides containing only WC and Co are referred to as
"straight grades," whereas those containing other metallic
carbides such as TiC, TaC, and NbC in addition to WC are called
"complex grades." The performance of these hardmetals has been limited by the
properties of the cobalt binder. |
| Genius
Metal Innovation
Genius Metal Inc. (Monrovia, CA) is aiming to shift the balance
between affordable carbides that tend to wear out quickly and expensive ceramics
that tend to last several times longer. Genius
is developing a new breed of carbides that lasts longer by replacing the
standard binder metal (i.e., cobalt) in the tungsten carbide matrix with
alternative metal binders that are much harder and have higher temperature resistance than cobalt. Cobalt does a good job of
binding the hard carbide phase in the tool, is tough, and can handle
repeated impacts as in interrupted
cutting. The new binder needs
to have the same binding ability yet handle heavy loads and impacts, too.
This is where some other efforts at alternative binders have failed
– and where ceramic tools are weakest!
However, the main weakness of cobalt is its low hardness and
melting temperature. The new
formulations from Genius go way beyond cobalt in terms of maintaining
hardness at high temperatures.
Test results have been extremely promising.
Independent materials testing labs have confirmed the unprecedented
hardness,
toughness, and temperature capabilities of the new tooling samples.
Recent independent machining trials have been also run by cutting
the superalloy Inconel 718 on a Haas CNC lathe. The tests, run at Cal Poly State University in San Luis
Obispo, directly compared samples made with traditional cobalt binder to several of
the new Genius Metal formulations with alternative metal binders.
In head-to-head trials, the new tooling lasted more
than twice as long as the cobalt-based tools. The figures below show results from cutting at 50 and 75 mpm
without coolant. The next
stage of development will involve coating the tools to boost performance
even further.
Co-1
and Co-3 are Cobalt-bonded Tungsten Carbide (Co-WC).
Gen-D, Gen-E, Gen-F, and Gen-G are Tungsten Carbide with
alternative binder metals from Genius Metal Inc.(www.geniusmetal.com).


The
best part of the new tooling is that they are still carbides at heart.
Since they still have the same toughness as traditional carbides, users won’t be limited to the small feeds and depths of cut required
with ceramics. And they also
won’t cost as much as ceramics. Because
the manufacturing involves essentially the same steps as producing
standard carbides, the cost will be comparable.
Genius estimates the purchase price will be about 20% more than
standard carbides simply due to the higher cost of the new binder
materials. For a quantum leap
in performance without having to make the switch to ceramics, it may well
be worth it.
Manufacturing
cost breakdown in typical machining process
Dr. Liu has applied high
temperature and high strength alloys to partially or completely replace the traditionally
used cobalt binder of hardmetals to greatly
improve hardness, toughness, eutectic temperature, and hot hardness.
Consequently, the new materials have combined properties
superior to those of Co-bound hardmetals as summarized below:
-
New materials are 30 to 50% harder
@ RT
-
New materials are 100% harder
@ 800C
-
New materials are 10 to 40%
tougher
-
Eutectic temperatures of new materials are 50 to 100% higher
-
New materials have much better environmental
and corrosion resistance
-
Coating Capability with CVD & PVD process demonstrated
Genius Metal has applied for 3 patents pertaining to these
revolutionary materials. The first was issued in June 2005 entitled
"Compositions and
Fabrication Methods for Hardmetals" (US 6, 911, 063). |
| Examples
of properties of Genius Metal's patented materials.
Representative Genius Metal grades
compared to typical commercially available hardmetals.
|
| Straight Grades (proprietary
alloy-bound WC) |
| Grade |
HV (kg/mm)*
2kg@Stork |
HV (kg/mm)
10kg@Genius |
TRS (KSI)*
@Stork |
Ksc (MPa.m0.5)
@Genius |
Eutectic Temperature (º C) |
| Gen-128 |
2743+-16 |
2639+-55 |
218+-65 |
6.3+-0.2 |
> 2500 |
| Gen-94 |
1555+-18 |
1591+-19 |
699+-37 |
12.4+-1.1 |
1400 |
| Gen-95 |
1295+-20 |
1303+-15 |
611+-31 |
21.6+-2 |
1400 |
| Commercial ISO-K01+ |
1850 |
|
210 |
|
1320 |
| Commercial ISO-K40+ |
1320 |
|
360 |
|
1320 |
| |
| Complex Grades (proprietary
alloy-bound WC+TiC+TaC) |
| Grade |
HV (kg/mm)*
2kg@Stork |
HV (kg/mm)
10kg@Genius |
TRS (KSI)*
@Stork |
Ksc (MPa.m0.5)
@Genius |
Eutectic Temperature (º C) |
| Gen-A |
2378+-87 |
2457+-23 |
237+-39 |
6.6+-0.1 |
> 2500 |
| Gen-135 |
1941+-47 |
1998+-34 |
321+-52 |
7.7+-0.2 |
1500 |
| Gen-136 |
1663+-58 |
1710+-25 |
413+-36 |
9.1+-0.3 |
1500 |
| Commercial ISO-P05+ |
1820 |
|
190 |
|
1320 |
| Commercial ISO-P40+ |
1420 |
|
335 |
|
1320 |
HV - Vickers Hardness
TRS - Transverse Rupture Strength (toughness)
Ksc - Fracture Toughness
* Stork Materials Testing & Inspection measured & provided certified
data.
+ Obtained from World Directory and Handbook
of Hardmetals and Hard Materials 6th ed.
| Test Data
Representative test data comparing key material
properties of some Genius Metal grades vs typical commercial grades.
Certified data from an independent test lab can be provided upon request. |
The hot hardness of Genius Metal P and K grade materials
far exceeds that of currently available commercial carbides. Genius
Metal grades can perform at elevated temperatures where comparable
materials have already reached failure due to superior eutectic
temperatures. |
Genius Metal ISO-K grades far exceed commercial ISO-K
grades simultaneously in terms of both toughness and hardness.
|
Genius Metal ISO-P grades far exceed commercial ISO-P
grades simultaneously in terms of both toughness and hardness.
Genius Metal P grades can also be used in applications where cermets are
typically used due to their high hardness. |
The transverse rupture strength as well as the hardness
of all Genius Metal grades is superior to that of any commercial K or P
grades.
|
|
Test Notes:
The International Organization of Standardization (ISO) issued ISO
Recommendation R513 "application of Carbides for machining by Chip
Removal." In the ISO system, all machining grades are divided into three
color-coded groups:
- *Highly alloyed complex grades (letter P) for machining
steel
- *Alloyed Complex grades (letter M, generally with less
TiC than the corresponding P grades) for multipurpose use, such as machining steels,
nickel-base superalloys, and ductile
cast iron.
- *Straight WC grades (letter K) for cutting gray cast iron,
nonferrous metals and nonmetallic materials.
|
|
|
|
 |